Resuscitation or Resurrection?

What is the difference between being resuscitated and resurrected? Lazarus was resuscitated in being brought back to the same life he had before dying. Eventually, he grew old and died again. Jesus, however, was resurrected. He was brought back to life, but not the same one as before. He was a new being, one who could hardly be recognized by his disciples at first. The new life in which he was resurrected into was one in which knows no more death. Jesus would not die again after having been resurrected into the fullness of Christ.

A seed turns into a plant or a flower, a caterpillar turns into a butterfly, and a tadpole turns into a frog. Each becomes a new thing, metamorphosed into a life changed radically. They are not resuscitated into what they once were, but become new creations of resurrection — made more beautiful from their transformation.

If you look into a chrysalis, what you discover is an empty tomb. The caterpillar is gone; not resuscitated, but resurrected. Now lives a butterfly. Caterpillars crawl and climb, but butterflies float and fly. The caterpillar seeks and struggles all its life to become something more beautiful. The butterfly already knows what it means to be beautiful, and therefore seeks not to help itself but rather to share its beauty, grace, and goodness with others. The desire of the caterpillar is to improve itself; that of the butterfly is to bless others. Whatever good the caterpillar does for others, it is done as part of an obligation or precondition to achieve its real self-interested goal. But the butterfly is not centered in self-interest. It lives to bless, not be blessed. It is the difference between caring for others out of principle and caring for them out of character…between loving them out of duty, and loving them out of the joy of doing so.

Being resuscitated brings us back to a life of the old fears, anxieties, and spiritual failings of the past. Being resurrected takes us to a new life in which we have no fear and no anxiety, and in which we are made complete and whole by love alone. To be resurrected into a life of perfect love is to know the peace that Christ gives to us…a peace not of this world, but of a world in which love -unconditional love- is the only thing that truly matters. God grant you the grace to be resurrected rather than resuscitated. May your life be an Easter miracle!

Review & Commentary

  • Paul Donnelly

    Brett, I liked your refreshing reflection on the resurrection. I think your reflection gives the Christian story a another perspective from the atonement theology that is embedded in this story.

  • Donald Laming

    “What is the difference between being resuscitated and resurrected? Lazarus was resuscitated in being brought back to the same life he had before dying. Eventually, he grew old and died again. Jesus, however, was resurrected. He was brought back to life, but not the same one as before. He was a new being, one who could hardly be recognized by his disciples at first.”

    This does not accord with the testimony that has come down to us in the New Testament gospels.

    John 19:34. A soldier pierces Jesus’ side with a spear and Jesus bleeds! At that point Jesus was still alive – unconscious, but not dead – because cadavers do not bleed.

    John 19:39. Nicodemus brings “ a mixture of myrrh and aloes, about an hundred pounds
    weight” to the tomb – the then medical treatment for oedema. John, Ch. 19 reads as though Joseph of Arimathe’a and Nicodemus had planned to resuscitate Jesus after his
    crucifixion.

    Most authoritative of all is Jesus’ own reported comment:

    See my hands and my feet, that it is I myself; handle me and see. …
    “Have you anything here to eat?” They gave him a piece of broiled fish, and he took it and ate before them. (Luke, 24:39-43).

    The difficulty faced by Jesus’ disciples (“… could hardly be recognized by his disciples at first.”) was that they supposed that Jesus had died on the cross!

  • Very nice, Bret. Thank you.